Charles Messier's 44 Comets

Charles Messier probably got first fascinated from a comet in 1744, still in Badonvilier, his Lorrainian hometown, as a 13-aged, when he observed the great 6-tailed comet which was subject to extensive studies by De Cheseaux.

As a young astronomer in Paris in 1758, he early became involved in the search for Halley's comet which was predicted for 1758-59. He specialized on hunting for comets, and successfully discovered about 20 of them, 13 original discoveries and 7 independent co-discoveries (but it is sometimes discussed where to put the limit; Jean-Paul Philbert tends to count comet 1801 Pons and that of 1762 Klinkenberg as another original discovery, as it occurred almost simultaneously with that of the original discoverers). Of the 50 comets of 1758-1806, when Messier actively searched for them, he observed and described a total of 44. A translation of his personal notes is available.

Below follows a table of the 44 comets Messier observed professionally:

No  Comet                Desig. new  old    Messier  Messier observed         d t  Disco. Date Discoverers

(0) Anonymus C/1743 X1 1744 - 1744 ? 1744 ?, De Cheseaux 1 De la Nux C/1758 K1 1758 1758 14-Aug-1758 02-Nov-1958 31 c 26-May-1758 De la Nux 2 P/Halley 1P/1758 Y1 1759I 1759 21-Jan-1759 01-May-1759 47 c 25-Dec-1758 Palitzsch 3 Great comet C/1760 A1 1759III 1760 1 08-Jan-1760 30-Jan-1760 6 c 07-Jan-1760 -many- (Chevalier) 4 Messier C/1760 B1 1759II 1760 2 26-Jan-1760 18-Mar-1760 22 ! 26-Jan-1760 Messier 5 Klinkenberg C/1762 K1 1762 1762 28-May-1762 05-Jul-1762 20 17-May-1762 Klinkenberg 6 Messier C/1763 S1 1763 1763 28-Sep-1763 24-Nov-1763 29 ! 28-Sep-1763 Messier 7 Messier C/1764 A1 1764 1764 03-Jan-1764 11-Feb-1764 16 ! 03-Jan-1764 Messier 8 Messier C/1766 E1 1766I 1766 1 08-Mar-1766 15-Mar-1766 8 ! 08-Mar-1766 Messier 9 P/Helfenzrieder D/1766 G1 1766II 1766 2 08-Apr-1766 12-Apr-1766 5 c 08-Apr-1766 Helfenzrieder 10 Messier C/1769 P1 1769 1769 08-Aug-1769 01-Dec-1769 42 ! 08-Aug-1769 Messier 11 P/Lexell D/1770 L1 1770I 1770 14-Jun-1770 03-Oct-1760 47 ! 14-Jun-1770 Messier 12 Great comet C/1771 A1 1770II 1771 1 10-Jan-1771 20-Jan-1771 4 c 10-Jan-1771 -many- (incl. Messier) 13 Messier C/1771 G1 1771 1771 2 01-Apr-1771 15-Jun-1771 48 ! 01-Apr-1771 Messier 14 P/Biela 3D/1772 E1 1772 1772 26-Mar-1772 03-Apr-1772 4 08-Apr-1772 Montaigne 15 Messier C/1773 T1 1773 1773 12-Oct-1773 14-Apr-1774 71 ! 12-Oct-1773 Messier 16 Montaigne C/1774 P1 1774 1774 18-Aug-1774 25-Oct-1774 41 11-Aug-1774 Montaigne 17 Bode C/1779 A1 1779 1779 19-Jan-1779 19-May-1779 63 c 06-Jan-1779 Bode 18 Messier C/1780 U2 1780I 1780 2 27-Oct-1780 28-Nov-1780 13 ! 27-Oct-1780 Messier 19 Mechain C/1781 M1 1781I 1781 1 30-Jun-1781 16-Jul-1781 14 28-Jun-1781 Mechain 20 Mechain C/1781 T1 1781II 1781 2 10-Oct-1781 05-Nov-1781 12 09-Oct-1781 Mechain 21 P/Pigott D/1783 W1 1783 1783 27-Nov-1783 21-Dec-1783 13 19-Nov-1783 Pigott 22 Great comet C/1783 X1 1784 1784 03-Feb-1784 25-May-1784 13 24-Jan-1784 -many- (Cassini) 23 Messier-Mechain C/1785 A1 1785I 1785 1 07-Jan-1785 16-Jan-1785 6 ! 07-Jan-1785 Messier 24 Mechain C/1785 E1 1785II 1785 2 13-Mar-1785 16-Apr-1785 14 11-Mar-1785 Mechain 25 P/Encke 2P/1786 B1 1786I 1786 1 19-Jan-1786 1 17-Jan-1786 Mechain 26 Herschel C/1786 P1 1786II 1786 2 01-Aug-1786 26 Oct 1786 43 C.Herschel 27 Mechain C/1787 G1 1787 1787 11-Apr-1787 20-May-1787 6 10-Apr-1787 Mechain 28 Messier C/1788 W1 1788I 1788 1 25-Nov-1788 29-Dec-1788 20 ! 25-Nov-1788 Messier 29 P/Herschel-Rigollet 35P/1788 Y1 1788II 1788 2 03-Jan-1789 06-Jan-1789 2 21-Dec-1788 C.Herschel 30 Herschel C/1790 A1 1790I 1790 1 19-Jan-1790 1 07-Jan-1790 C.Herschel 31 P/Tuttle 8P/1790 A2 1790II 1790 2 10-Jan-1790 7 09-Jan-1790 Mechain 32 Herschel C/1790 H1 1790III 1790 3 01-May-1790 09-Jun-1790 45 17-Apr-1790 C.Herschel 33 Herschel C/1791 X1 1792I 1791 26-Dec-1791 28-Jan-1792 12 15-Dec-1791 C.Herschel 34 Gregory C/1793 A1 1792II 1793 1 01-Feb-1793 14-Feb-1793 6 10-Jan-1793 Gregory, Mechain 35 Perny C/1793 S1 1793II 1793 3 27-Sep-1793 08-Dec-1793 25 24-Sep-1793 Perny 36 Messier C/1793 S2 1793I 1793 4 27-Sep-1793 07-Jan-1794 ! 27-Sep-1793 Messier 37 Bouvard-Herschel-Lee C/1797 P1 1797 1797 16-Aug-1797 30-Aug-1797 13 14-Aug-1797 Bouvard 38 Messier C/1798 G1 1798I 1798 1 12-Apr-1798 24-May-1798 27 ! 12-Apr-1798 Messier 39 Bouvard C/1798 X1 1798II 1798 2 07-Dec-1798 12-Dec-1798 4 06-Dec-1798 Bouvard 40 Mechain C/1799 P1 1799I 1799 1 10-Aug-1799 25-Oct-1799 44 07-Aug-1799 Mechain 41 Mechain C/1799 Y1 1799II 1799 2 28-Dec-1799 06-Jan-1800 5 26-Dec-1799 Mechain 42 Pons C/1801 N1 1801 1801 12-Jul-1801 21-Jul-1801 5 c 12-Jul-1801 Pons, Messier, Mechain, Bouvard 43 Pons C/1802 Q1 1802 1802 30-Aug-1802 05-Sep-1802 7 26-Aug-1802 Pons 44 Pons C/1804 E1 1804 1804 11-Mar-1804 17-Mar-1804 6 07-Mar-1804 Pons
Key:
No
Messier's numbering for "his" comets (i.e., those he observed)
Comet
Comet Name/Discoverer[s]
Desig.
Comet Designation: New IAU desgination; Old style "Final" designation: year and Roman number for perihelion passage; and Messier's designation
Messier observed
Dates between Messier observed the comet
d
Number of days (nights) Messier saw the comet
t
Type of discovery (if any): "!": Original discovery, "c": Independent co-discovery, "?": Perhaps an independent co-discovery
Disco. Date
Discovery Date
Discoverers
Name(s) of (original) discoverer(s)
Additional Resources and Notes on some of these comets:
2. 1P/Halley (1758 Y1, 1759I Palitzsch)
Charles Messier and Comet Halley; Messier's Memoir and observations, Phil. Trans LV, 294 (1765); Gary Kronk's Comet 1P/Halley page; More info and links on Comet 1P/Halley
7. C/1764 Messier (C/1764 A1, 1764 Messier)
Messier's observations, Phil. Trans LIV, 151 (1764)
8. C/1766 Messier (C/1766 E1, 1766I Messier)
Messier's observations, Phil. Trans LVI, 57 (1766)
9. D/1766 Helfenzrieder (D/1766 G1, 1766 Helfenzrieder-Messier)
Messier's observations, Phil. Trans LVI, 57 (1766); Gary Kronk's Comet D/1766 G1 Helfenzrieder page
10. C/1769 Messier (C/1769 P1, 1769 Messier)
Bessel obtained an orbital period of 2090 years for this comet.
11. D/1770 Lexell (D/1770 L1, 1770I Messier)
This comet had become short-period of only 5.6 years by being captured by Jupiter in 1767. Its next return occurred in 1776 but in daylight so that it was not observed. In 1779, it was again perturbed by Jupiter and has not returned since, as it probably was ejected from the inner solar system..
Gary Kronk's Comet D/1770 L1 Lexell page
12. C/1771 "Great Comet" (C/1771 A1, 1770II "Great Comet")
Messier's observations, Phil. Trans LXI, 104 (1771)
14. 3D/Biela (3D/1772 E1, 1772 Montaigne); (3D/1805 V1, 1806I Pons)
This comet was found to have a 6.62-year period (the 3rd periodic comet) by Biela in 1826, split in two pieces in January 1846, one of them recovered last in 1852 (last observation Sep 29). Later meteor showers have been associeted with it. In 2001 it was noted (by S. Nakano) that Comet P/2001 J1 (NEAT) had a similar orbit, giving room for speculations that it might be associated with 3D/Biela in some way. (IAUC 7635)
Gary Kronk's Comet 3D/Biela page
17. C/1779 Bode (C/1779 A1).
Chart of its track or path online.
25. 2P/Encke (2P/1786 B1, 1786I Mechain); (2P/1795 V1, 1795 Herschel)
The 1795 aparation (Caroline Herschel's discovery) was not observed by Charles Messier, because of years of trouble in France. Gary Kronk's Comet 2P/Encke page; Images of 2P/Encke (JPL)
31. 8P/Tuttle (8P/1790 A2, 1790II Mechain)
Gary Kronk's Comet 8P/Tuttle page
References:


  • More Comet Links


    Hartmut Frommert (spider@seds.org)
    Christine Kronberg (smil@lrz.uni-muenchen.de)

    [SEDS] [MAA] [Home] [M History Home] [Indexes]

    Last Modification: 9 Apr 2000, 12:00 MET